Google Ads or Meta Ads for a local business? How to choose

Google Ads or Meta Ads for a local business? How to choose

If you run a local business and want more enquiries, two names come up almost immediately: Google Ads and Meta Ads (Facebook and Instagram).

Both can work. Both can also waste money if they’re used for the wrong job. The trick isn’t finding out which one is “better”. It’s understanding what each one is good at, and then testing them honestly for your own business.

Intent versus interruption

The simplest way to think about it is this.

Google search ads meet people who are already looking. Someone types “home tutor near me” or “AC repair in my area”, and your ad appears right there. They have a need, and they’re actively searching for a solution.

Meta ads reach people who weren’t looking. Someone is scrolling through their feed, catching up with friends, and your ad appears in between. They didn’t ask for it, but if it’s relevant and well made, it can catch their attention and create interest.

One captures demand that already exists. The other helps create it. That one difference shapes almost everything else.

Side by side

Google search ads

  • Shown when someone searches for something related to your business
  • You choose keywords, the words people type
  • Ads are mostly text, so the offer and the wording matter most
  • People are already looking, so they’re often closer to getting in touch
  • You can only reach as many people as are searching for what you offer

Meta ads (Facebook and Instagram)

  • Shown while people scroll through their feeds and stories
  • You choose audiences, such as people in a certain area or with certain interests
  • Ads are visual, so the image or video matters most
  • People weren’t looking, so the ad has to earn their attention
  • You can reach people before they ever think to search

Neither list makes one platform cheaper or better. They’re different tools for different moments.

When search tends to fit

Search tends to suit businesses where people go looking when a need appears. Think of repairs, local services, tuition or anything urgent. If people in your area already search for what you offer, search ads put you in front of them at exactly the right moment.

When social tends to fit

Social ads tend to suit businesses with something visual to show, a new offer people don’t know about yet, or a service people don’t think to search for. They’re also useful for staying in front of people who visited your website but didn’t get in touch.

Why many local businesses test both

In reality, the line isn’t always clear. A tuition service, for example, could be found through search by parents who are actively looking, and could also reach parents on social media who hadn’t started looking yet.

That’s why many local businesses run a careful test of both, rather than picking one based on opinion. The test tells you what actually works for your area, your offer and your customers.

Set up tracking before you spend anything

Before you spend anything on either platform, make sure you can see where each enquiry comes from. That means labelled links, a form that records the source, and a simple lead sheet where every real enquiry gets a row.

Without this, you’ll end up comparing each platform’s own reports. Each one counts in its own way, so those reports rarely give a fair comparison.

The exact settings change over time, so check the current screen in each ad account when you set up conversion tracking.

Test for a fixed period, then judge by your own numbers

Pick a fixed period and a budget you’re comfortable with for each platform. Keep the offer and the landing page the same, so you’re comparing the platforms rather than two different offers.

At the end of the period, look at your own lead sheet:

  • How many real, de-duplicated enquiries came from each platform?
  • What did each enquiry cost, using what you actually spent?
  • How good were those enquiries? Did they turn into conversations, or were they mostly not a fit?

Judge by the cost per lead you measured yourself, not by averages you read on the internet. Every business, area and offer is different, and someone else’s numbers can’t tell you what will happen in yours.

Example: if one platform brings in fewer enquiries but more of them turn into real conversations, it may be the better choice even if it looks more expensive at first.

Key takeaway

Google search ads catch people who are already looking. Meta ads reach people who weren’t looking yet. Set up tracking first, test both for a fixed period, and decide based on the cost per lead and lead quality you measured yourself.

If you’re not sure which platform suits your business, I’m happy to talk it through.

← Back to all articles